Penelope's Old Time Burgers

Tina Foster

After 40 years living in Northern Colorado, day trips to Estes Park, FINALLY got to try this Burger Joint. No waiting, February 02, 2025. Not tourist season , no line. We got the regular burger and French fries. So delicious! The beef burger is handmade, not some pre frozen patty. It was cooked and seasoned to perfection! It has caramelize onions, served with lettuce, tomato and yummy pickle. The French fries were spot on, homemade fries with a little skin. Absolutely delicious Well worth the drive in winter!

Nick E

This is a cool burger joint in downtown Eates Park. After a long morning, we wanted something good for lunch and this did not disappoint! The burger was great and the queso cheese fries were a nice twist on what we are used to. The kids menu was great for our daughter too! This place was busy at lunch time on a Tuesday. Pricing was a bit higher than expected but seems typical for other places in the area. Will eat here again!

Nguyen Le

The best Bison Burger and Elk Burger i ever had. I order double patties of both burger and onion fries and sweet potatoes fries. It was amazing. The onion fries was so crispy (my style). Dont miss this place when you are in town

Sage Isenhart

The burgers are spectacular. The 2/3 LB burgers are huge and have very good flavoring. I won’t be getting anymore sides unless it’s the traditional fries. I got the sweet potato fries and they didn’t cook them well. Definitely frozen before cooking and though I appreciate the quick service, neither the onion rings or sweet potato fries were good. $50 for 2 cheese burgers, sides, and 1 drink

Yunior Mendez

Best burgers ! You have to try the one with the jalapeño on top. It is a little spicy but incredibly delicious! Also, the elk one is so good.