Captain Hook Seafood

Kodiak Bay (YamaJa)

My wife and I dined here, and our experience was outstanding. We visited on one of their first Saturdays after opening, and I ordered the Crawfish Boil while my wife chose the Mussel Boil. Both dishes were exceptional. I sincerely hope this restaurant thrives here in Fort Collins, as we will definitely be returning. Additionally, the spice level was balanced—not overwhelming—but certainly enough to leave my nose running by the end!

Becki P

We were very excited to try a new restaurant and a seafood one at that! We arrive and were promptly seated by our server. We started to the crab bites and they came with a sauce on the side . The bites themselves were good and the sauce had a good complimentary flavor. I would’ve enjoyed a cocktail sauce as well but I’m partial to more acidic flavors. We ordered a kids meal boil , a head off shrimp boil and a fried shrimp basket . The servings were generous and the Cajun option we chose for the boils were flavorful and not too spicy. I would’ve enjoyed have liked some lemons in the side and cocktail / tartar sauce option but also didn’t think it so important to ask for. We paid from the table but they’d didn’t have the check presenter yet which was a little odd. They are newly opened and I believe they’ll figure out the little things as time goes on. Overall I would recommend it.

Travel B

What a wonderful experience! They are still waiting for their liquor license, but once they have that, they'll have a nice large bar area. The seafood was fantastic. I had the shrimp boil with medium spiced lemon pepper garlic butter. The flavor was wonderful and the shrimp were large and cooked to perfection! I would have enjoyed a few more potatoes and could have done without the corn, but it was all delicious! I was given a disposable bib and gloves to avoid getting to messy. The catfish basket with sweet potato fries was also delicious. We had an order of hush puppies that were tasty, enough to share, and a great price!! The staff was happy and helpful. I'll definitely visit again and I recommend you try it!! Lunch prices were very fair, dinner prices seemed a bit high, but you're getting yummy seafood in Colorado, so just pay it! The seat in our booth was badly torn and I feel they should have taken care of that detail before opening, but overall it was a fun seaside atmosphere!

Cherie G

I was ready to be unimpressed—the spacious seating was mostly empty at lunchtime and the decorations are kitschy (giant plastic crab 🦀 ). However the food was good. We had fried oyster basket and flounder basket—portions are large and shareable. We started with clam chowder which was smooth, and not overly floured with clams on tops. The corn cobs were not mushy. The fish was lightly breaded and the dipping sauce has a nice piquant bite. The fries are crisp and tasty. The serving staff were all polite but still a bit new at their jobs and we had to ask someone to finally take our order. Prices are reasonable. This would be a good family night out. Music is too loud for me but maybe not you.

Michelle Mueller

5 stars all around!!! Yaya was our server and she was so kind and gave great recommendations on what to order. My husband and I were on a date and she offered to take our picture. We shared a boil and it was the perfect amount of food for us!! The flavor was INCREDIBLE!!! The atmosphere was GREAT!!! My husband and I loved the chain decorations. We are taking our young adult kids there next time!!! FABULOUS food and service!!! The ABSOLUTE best EVER onion rings I have ever had. They had a light and flaking coating and the onion was cooked PERFECTLY!!! YUM.