Antonio's Real New York Pizza
Specialties: Antonio's specializes in Real New York Pizza- thin-crust round and thick-crust Sicilian made just the way they're made back home on Long Island. In addition to NY pies, we make Neapolitan(Italian style) pizza as well with our own homemade fresh mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes from Italy. All of our dough and sauce is made in-house, daily and just like in NY, our dough is fermented for days! You will not find fresher ingredients anywhere, nor a more authentic experience. Why? Because we are actually from Long Island. Antonio and his wife, Tracey are 4th generation Italian New Yorkers, their children are 5th generation. We also learned regional specialties like the Detroit Red Top pizza and Chicago's Tavern style. In addition to pizza, we have BAGELS! Yes, they are kettled, yes they are made by hand and yes the recipe is from NY! Tracey makes cannoli using her family recipe, and all of our bread is baked here. When taste and authenticity matter, come to Antonio's Real NY Pizza. Established in 2014. Antonio began making pizza in 2010 because he missed the taste of home just like so many who move to a new place. Had he not moved to Colorado from Long Island, Antonio's would never have existed. In 2014, Antonio took the leap and rented a restaurant to see whether New York Pizza would take off in Estes Park, Colorado. By 2016, Food Network Magazine chose us as one of the Top Restaurants in Rocky Mountain National Park. In 2018, we bought a 200 seat building and took our show to a larger venue. We have two state-of-the-art deck ovens that were custom made in Sweden. Combined, they hold 36 large 18" pies at the same time! We also make 26" and 36" pies. Antonio was inducted into the World Pizza Champions in August 2021 for his contributions to the local community and the integrity he brought to the pizza community. In 2023, The Washington Post named Antonio's Estes Park location the best New York Pizzeria in the State of Colorado!
#Pizza
#Italian
Delivery
During hours
The vendor will reach out to confirm the most convenient delivery or pickup option for you.
Payment
Amanda Curtis
Mar 21, 2025
The pizza, wings and garlic knots were all very good. Best pizza I have had in a long time! I love how you can get the wings extra well done. The sauce on the pizza was delicious and the crust was perfect.
Het Patel
Mar 27, 2025
Must-Try Spot in Estes Park – Don’t Skip the Wings, Chicago-Style Pizza, and Garlic Knots! Antonio’s Real New York Pizza in Estes Park is an absolute must-visit! While their New York-style pizza is top-notch, don’t miss out on their incredible wings, flavorful Chicago-style deep-dish pizza, and perfectly baked garlic knots. The wings are crispy and coated in delicious sauces, the deep-dish pizza is loaded with gooey cheese and rich tomato sauce, and the garlic knots are the perfect starter—soft, buttery, and packed with garlic flavor. The New York-style pizza is the real deal—thin, foldable, with the perfect balance of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and melty cheese. Every bite feels like a slice straight from the streets of NYC. One thing to note is that they do charge for water, but I actually appreciate their reasoning. It helps conserve water, reducing unnecessary waste—a thoughtful and responsible move. Given how much water gets wasted at restaurants, this policy makes sense. Plus, it’s a small trade-off for their fantastic food and service. The atmosphere is welcoming, and the staff is friendly and efficient. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice, indulging in a deep-dish pie, or sharing a plate of wings, you’ll leave satisfied. Highly recommend stopping by if you’re in Estes Park!
Giulia Zanella
Apr 06, 2025
We decided to come here after reading that the owner went to Italy for some type of pizza competition. The owner of my favorite restaurant in Italy also does the same competition, so I was expecting a pizza as good as the Italian one. The food was great, but it wasn't as good as I was expecting it to be. I was just expecting Italian pizza, but it's NY pizza. The garlic knots were dry, but very good with some marinara sauce. The pizza was delicious and so full of pepperoni! The calzone was even better! I took away a star only because it's not a place I would go again when I visit Estes Park, but it was still great food and even better service!
Jeremy kuhlman
May 26, 2025
Absolutely amazing food and service. Antonio and Tracey have absolutely nailed it! We had the perfect experience, including visiting with the owners and their passion for food and quality is definitely top notch! They also have a bakery inside that was unexpected and a hidden gem to literally add the ”icing on the cake” Being from Chicago, I was in heaven that they had Chicago style pizza so we ordered one to go, but the star of the show was the Sicilian pizza, as shown in the pictures. 💯/ 💯 would recommend, and we will DEFINITELY be back.
Alyssa Vester
Jun 05, 2025
The food is amazing! The service and atmosphere could use some updating.. but I also think that could be based on personal preferences. We didn't love how impersonal it felt having to turn a card for service and to have a robot deliver the food. But I also saw some families really enjoy that aspect. We've visited as a couple only and feel our 4 kids would think the robot is so cool, we can't wait to take them to check it out.
Antonio's Real New York Pizza in the Cafes/Restaurants category
Address: 1560 Big Thompson Ave,Estes Park, CO 80517
Working hours:
Payment: cash
Delivery with clarification: we will call you back to clarify the most convenient delivery method.
Antonio's Real New York Pizza on the map